Order Carlo's

Dine in with us, call ahead for pickup, or get Carlo's delivered to your door.

The Best Way to Eat Carlo's

The best way to enjoy our food is the way families have done it since 1986: right here with us in Shirley. A pie fresh out of the oven, served hot at your table, tastes the way it is supposed to taste. Come in, sit down, and let our family take care of yours.

In a hurry? Call ahead and we will have your order hot and ready for pickup at the counter. Or open directions in the maps app you like best:

Call (631) 924-8760 Get Directions

Frank and his father, founders of Carlo's Pizzeria in Shirley, NY, established 1986

Order Delivery

Cannot make it in? Carlo's is also available for delivery through these third-party services. Pick your favorite and they will bring Carlo's to you.

Delivery and pickup through DoorDash.

Order on DoorDash

Delivery and pickup through Grubhub.

Order on Grubhub

Delivery and pickup through Uber Eats.

Order on Uber Eats

Please note: Carlo's does not offer its own delivery. Delivery is provided by independent third-party services: DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats. We make your food in our kitchen, and the service you choose picks it up and delivers it. Because of that, delivery times, delivery fees, and the handling of your order once it leaves our store are the responsibility of that service, not Carlo's. Prices and items on third-party apps may differ from our in-store menu. If anything goes wrong with a delivery, please contact the service you ordered through so they can make it right.

Pizza served fresh on a wooden tray at Carlo's Pizzeria in Shirley, NY