Our Menu
Authentic Italian dishes and pizza in Shirley, NY, made from family recipes since 1986.
Most Ordered
- Neapolitan (Large)$27.00
- Garlic Knots (Dozen)$8.00
- Regular Slice$4.90
- Salad Slice$7.25
- Wings$8.50
- Pepperoni Wheel$6.50
- Sicilian (12 Slices)$30.00
- Neapolitan (Small)$22.00
- Meatball Parmigiana$13.00
- Sicilian Slice$5.20
- Caesar Salad$11.50
- Penne ala Vodka$23.00
Pizza
- Plain Pizza$21.00
- Vodka Pie$35.00
- Grandma's Pizza$32.00
- Margherita Pizza$32.00
- Sicilian Pie$30.00
- Buffalo Chicken$35.00
- Chicken & Broccoli Pizza$32.00
- Deep Dish Meat$35.00
- Carlo's Special (Large 16")$30.00
- Carlo's Special (Small 14")$26.00
- Cauliflower Crust Personal Pie$18.00
- Gluten Free$18.00
Italian Favorites
- Eggplant Parmigiana$21.40
- Sausage and Peppers Parmigiana$20.30
- Carlo's Special$20.30
- Chicken & Sausage Campagnola$21.40
- Eggplant Rollatini$21.40
- Pasta Pleasure Combo$22.00
- Carlo's Delight$20.30
- Carlo's Italian Surf & Turf$25.95
- Chicken Parmigiana$24.00
- Baked Ziti$18.00
- Spaghetti with Meatball or Sausage$21.00
Hot Heros
- Meatball Parmigiana$13.00
- Chicken Parm Hero$14.00
- Chicken Francaise Parmigiana$14.00
- Sausage & Peppers$12.50
- Eggplant Parmigiana$12.50
- Meatball$11.00
- Chicken Bacon Ranch$12.50
- Sausage Parmigiana$12.50
- Buffalo Chicken Parmigiana$13.50
- Potatoes & Eggs$10.00
- Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana$11.00
- Shrimp Parmigiana$16.00
- Broccoli Rabe Parmigiana$13.80
- Chicken & Roasted Peppers$12.50
- Chicken Club$13.00
- Chicken Marsala Parmigiana$12.75
- Peppers & Eggs$10.00
- Sausage & Egg$11.25
- Steak & Cheese$11.25
- Veal & Mushroom$13.00
- Veal & Mushroom Parmigiana$13.00
- Veal & Pepper Parmigiana$13.00
- Meatballs & Peppers$12.50
- Sausage$11.90
- Sausage & Potatoes$12.50
- BBQ Chicken Hero$14.55
- Veal Cutlet Parmigiana$14.50
- Veal & Peppers$13.50
- Italian Cold Cuts Hero$14.00
Paninis
- Eggplant with Roasted Red Pepper Panini$9.00
- Blackened Chicken Panini$9.00
- Chicken with Roasted Red Pepper Panini$9.00
- Chicken, Lettuce and Tomato Panini$9.00
Soups & Salads
- Chicken Soup (Pint)$8.00
- Chicken Soup (Quart)$12.95
- Pasta Fagioli (Pint)$8.00
- Pasta Fagioli (Quart)$12.95
- Lentil Soup (Pint)$8.00
- Lentil Soup (Quart)$12.95
- Seafood Bisque (Pint)$9.00
- Seafood Bisque (Quart)$13.95
- Italian Wedding Soup$9.00
- Tossed Garden Salad$9.55
- Tossed Salad (Small)$7.25
- Caesar Salad$10.20
- Caesar Salad (Small)$8.35
- Greek Salad$11.35
- Greek Salad (Small)$8.35
- Antipasto Salad (Boar's Head)$12.60
- Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil$11.95
- Italian Chef Salad$10.75
- Italian Chef Salad (Small)$8.35
- Chicken Bacon Cheddar Salad$11.35
- Chicken Bacon Cheddar Salad (Small)$9.60
- Scungilli Salad$13.15
Appetizers & Sides
- Garlic Knots (6)$6.00
- Garlic Knots (Dozen)$8.00
- Wings$8.50
- Pepperoni Wheel$6.50
- Mussels Marinara$13.75
- Chicken Roll$14.00
Dessert
- CannoliAsk in store
Please note: Prices subject to change. Call (631) 924-8760 to confirm. Ready to order? Call us for pickup, or get it delivered through DoorDash, Grubhub, or Uber Eats.